Masonry vs. Metal Chimneys: Which is Best for Your Home?

If you live in Syracuse or surrounding towns like Baldwinsville, Cicero, Liverpool, or Fayetteville, your chimney isn’t just a feature—it’s a workhorse during our long, snowy winters. You may be wondering: Should I go with a traditional masonry chimney or a modern metal chimney?

Both have their strengths, but the best choice depends on your home’s style, your heating needs, and our unique Central New York climate.

Masonry Chimneys

Built from brick, stone, or concrete blocks, masonry chimneys are the classic style found in many older homes across CNY.

Pros:

• Durability: With proper maintenance, masonry chimneys can last decades—even generations.

• Aesthetics: They add timeless curb appeal and pair beautifully with historic and traditional homes in neighborhoods like Skaneateles or Jamesville.

• Heat Retention: The brick absorbs heat, radiating warmth into your home even after the fire goes out.

Cons:

• Cost: Masonry chimneys are more expensive to build.

• Maintenance: Central New York’s freeze-thaw cycles can crack mortar and brick if not waterproofed.

• Weight: They require a strong foundation, which can increase installation costs.

Metal Chimneys

Usually made from stainless steel or galvanized metal, metal chimneys (also called factory-built or prefabricated chimneys) are lightweight, modular systems.

Pros:

• Lower Cost: Typically more affordable to install than masonry.

• Flexibility: Can be installed in homes without an existing chimney or in locations where a masonry build isn’t practical.

• Weather Resistance: High-quality stainless steel can handle CNY winters well, especially if insulated.

Cons:

• Shorter Lifespan: While durable, they usually don’t last as long as brick or stone.

• Aesthetics: Metal chimneys don’t have the same traditional look as masonry, though chimney surrounds can improve appearance.

• Noise: Rain or sleet hitting a metal chimney can be louder than on brick.

Masonry or Metal Chimney in Central New York?

No matter which you choose, regular inspections and maintenance are key—especially in Syracuse’s harsh winters. From waterproofing brick to checking metal joints for rust, proper care keeps your chimney safe and efficient.

Need help deciding between masonry and metal for your CNY home?

We serve Syracuse, Baldwinsville, Cicero, Liverpool, Fayetteville, and surrounding towns with expert chimney inspections, repairs, and installations. Call Block Solid Masonry today to schedule an on-site visit!